When co-executors cannot agree - Roper v Berry & Another [2026] QSC 234
Lady-smiling

When co-executors cannot agree - Roper v Berry & Another [2026] QSC 234

New

Alannah Nugent, Avant Law - Paralegal

Evelyn Burke-Shyne, Avant Law - Special Counsel, Estate Planning

New

Appointing more than one executor can provide valuable oversight and shared responsibility in the administration of an estate. However, where co-executors cannot work together, disagreements can delay the administration, increase legal costs and substantially reduce the assets ultimately available to beneficiaries.

The recent Supreme Court of Queensland decision in Roper v Berry & Another [2026] QSC 234 illustrates these risks. It also highlights the difficulties that may arise when a Will does not clearly explain how the deceased’s property is to be administered and distributed.[1]

Require assistance with your Estate Planning?

Reach out for a complimentary initial consultation.

A modest estate caught in prolonged conflict

The deceased died in April 2021, leaving a handwritten “kit Will”. Two of his daughters were appointed as executors, with another daughter appointed as the alternative executor. Probate was granted to the two executors on 29 October 2021.[2]

The estate comprised land near Charters Towers, various vehicles, machinery and other chattels, together with funds held in two bank accounts. Its total value was estimated at approximately $427,817.87.[3]

Despite probate having been granted in 2021, the administration had made little progress. Although the executors had jointly obtained valuations of the land and chattels in 2022, the Court found that nothing meaningful had occurred since then. Johnstone J described the delay as “profound”.[4]

By the time the matter came before the Court, all three parties were legally represented, and several hearings had already occurred. Counsel acknowledged that, unless the estate administration was finalised soon, the vast majority of the estate could be lost to legal fees.[5]

The case is a stark reminder that executor disputes can quickly become disproportionate to the value of the estate itself.

The difficulties created by an unclear Will

A significant source of the conflict was clause 5 of the Will. Among other things, it stated that, “my property is to stay in the family for my sons to live in the family home”.[6] It also purported to direct the executors to maintain the property and pay its rates from the sons’ bank accounts.[7]

The respondents argued that the clause created a life interest in the property for the deceased’s three sons. The applicant contended that it did not.[8]

The Court reiterated that its role is to ascertain the deceased’s intention from the language of the Will. While a court will endeavour to avoid an intestacy and may allow some latitude where a person has prepared their own Will, it cannot rewrite the document to produce an outcome that the deceased may have intended but did not adequately express.[9]

In this case, the Will did not establish a testamentary trust or explain:

  • who was to own the property;
  • who was responsible for its ongoing expenses;
  • what would happen if one or more of the sons did not live there;
  • whether other family members could occupy it; or
  • what was to happen to the property after the sons died or ceased using it.[10]

The Court concluded that the relevant words expressed no more than a wish. They did not dispose of the property or create a life interest or other beneficial interest in favour of the sons.[11]

A person can only give away property they own.

The directions concerning the sons’ bank accounts were also invalid. Under s 8(1) of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld), a Will disposes of property to which the deceased was entitled at the time of death. The deceased could not, through his Will, give the executors control over bank accounts that belonged to his sons or direct that money from those accounts be used to maintain the estate property.[12]

Any powers of attorney held by the deceased in relation to his sons also ended when the deceased died. The executors would only have been entitled to deal with those accounts if they had some separate and valid authority to do so.[13]

These findings reinforce an important estate-planning principle; a Will-maker can only dispose of property forming part of their estate. A Will cannot transfer another person’s property or extend an authority that ended upon the Will-maker’s death.

The unintended partial intestacy

As clause 5 did not effectively dispose of the land, that part of the estate was required to be administered under the intestacy provisions in pt 3 of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld).[14]

This produced an unintended consequence. Elsewhere in the Will, the deceased had made a specific gift of $100 to one daughter and stated that this was to be his only gift to her. However, because the land had not been validly disposed of, that daughter remained entitled to share in the intestate portion of the estate.[15]

The outcome illustrates the limits of clauses intended to restrict or exclude a beneficiary. Even if a Will-maker clearly states that a person is to receive only a nominal gift, that person may still benefit if other estate property has not been effectively disposed of under the Will.

Does conflict justify removing an executor?

The applicant also sought the removal of the first respondent as executor. The Supreme Court of Queensland has power to remove an executor under s 6 of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld), relevant provisions governing trustees and its inherent jurisdiction.[16]

The Court accepted that there had been conflict between the co-executors and that the conflict had contributed to the delay. However, disagreement or hostility between executors does not, by itself, necessarily justify removal. As explained in Re Permewan, the existence of conflict is relevant, but it is not necessarily determinative. The question is the extent of the conflict and its likely effect on the administration of the estate.[17]

The Court’s focus is therefore not on punishing an executor or deciding which party is personally responsible for the breakdown in the relationship. The central concern is whether the conflict prevents the estate from being properly administered.

In Roper v Berry, the dispute about the meaning of clause 5 appeared to be a significant cause of the disagreement between the executors. The Court considered that resolving the construction issue might remove the principal obstacle and allow the administration to proceed.[18]

Once that issue was resolved, the remaining steps appeared relatively straightforward. The executors were required to sell the land and chattels and distribute the proceeds in accordance with the Will and the intestacy rules. The Court also observed that there appeared to be no reason why a beneficiary could not purchase the property for fair market value.[19]

For that reason, the Court declined to remove the first respondent at that point. Instead, the removal application was adjourned. Johnstone J expressly noted that the position might change if conflict between the executors continued.[20]

The decision should not be understood as suggesting that the delay was acceptable. Rather, it reflects the Court’s decision not to remove an executor where resolving the central construction dispute might enable the executors to complete the administration without further intervention.

Practical lessons for Will-makers and executors

The decision offers several important lessons.

First, appointing multiple executors requires careful consideration. Co-executors ordinarily need to make important decisions together. If the proposed executors have a strained relationship, fundamentally different views about the estate or an inability to communicate effectively, their appointment may create delay rather than provide additional protection.

Secondly, expressions of hope or intention may not create legally enforceable rights. A direction that a property should ‘stay in the family’ may sound clear in everyday language, but it does not necessarily identify who is to own the property, who may occupy it, how expenses are to be paid or when the arrangement comes to an end.

Where a Will-maker wants a beneficiary to occupy a property, the Will should clearly address:

  • the nature and duration of the beneficiary’s right to occupy the property;
  • who is responsible for rates, insurance, maintenance and repairs;
  • whether the beneficiary must pay rent or other occupation expenses;
  • when the property may or must be sold;
  • what happens if the beneficiary permanently leaves the property; and
  • who ultimately receives the property or the proceeds of its sale.

Thirdly, a person can only dispose of by Will property that forms part of their estate (i.e. held in their personal name). A Will cannot transfer another person’s bank account or continue a power of attorney beyond the Will-maker’s death.

Finally, executor disputes should be addressed promptly. Prolonged correspondence, inactivity and litigation can consume an estate, particularly where its value is modest. Executors should obtain legal advice early if they disagree about the meaning of the Will or the steps required to complete the administration.

Clear drafting can prevent costly disputes

Roper v Berry demonstrates how uncertain drafting and executor conflict can compound one another. An unclear Will created a genuine dispute about the deceased’s intentions, while the executors’ inability to resolve that dispute left the estate substantially unadministered for several years.

Carefully prepared estate planning documents cannot prevent every family disagreement. They can, however, reduce ambiguity, establish workable arrangements and give executors clearer guidance about how the estate is to be administered.

For Will-makers, the case reinforces the value of obtaining legal advice rather than relying on a homemade document. For executors, it is a reminder that personal disagreements must not be allowed to prevent the timely and proper administration of an estate.

Should you wish to discuss any aspect of your estate planning, please call 1800 867 113, or to organise a confidential discussion at a time that suits you, please click here.

[1] Roper v Berry & Another [2026] QSC 234 (‘Roper v Berry’)

[2] Ibid [5]–[6].

[3] Ibid [7]–[10].

[4] Ibid [11], [15].

[5] Ibid [10].

[6] Ibid [32], [36(c)].

[7] Ibid [36(d)]–[36(e)].

[8] Ibid [45]–[46].

[9] Ibid [30]–[31], citing Fell v Fell (1922) 31 CLR 268, 274 and Re Rodgers [2002] 1 Qd R 543, 546.

[10] Roper v Berry (n 1) [48]–[50], [63].

[11] Ibid [55], [64].

[12] Succession Act 1981 (Qld) s 8(1); Roper v Berry (n 1) [39]–[42].

[13] Roper v Berry (n 1) [41].

[14] Ibid [65]; Succession Act 1981 (Qld) pt 3.

[15] Roper v Berry (n 1) [20], [65].

[16] Ibid [66]; Succession Act 1981 (Qld) s 6.

[17] Re Permewan [2021] QSC 151, [47], quoted in Roper v Berry (n 1) [67].

[18] Roper v Berry (n 1) [68]–[70].

[19] Ibid [70].

[20] Ibid [71]–[73].

Legal services are provided by Avant Law Pty Ltd (ACN 136 429 153) (Avant Law). Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.  Legal practitioners employed by Avant Law are members of the scheme.

The information in this article does not constitute legal advice or other professional advice and should not be relied upon as such. It is intended only to provide a summary and general overview on matters of interest and it is not intended to be comprehensive. You should seek legal or other professional advice before acting or relying on any of this content. The information in this article is current to 19 November 2026.