Psychiatrist’s relationship with former patient still inappropriate five years after treating relationship ceased
Sunday, 16 July 2023
Key messages from the case
Relationships with former patients may be in breach of sexual boundaries guidelines. Generally, the time elapsed between ending the treating relationship and starting a personal relationship will be relevant. However sexual relationships between psychiatrists and former patients will always be regarded as unethical.
Details of the decision
Boundary violations - former patients
Psychiatrist, Dr L provided intensive psychotherapy to patient EK for dysthymic (depressive) disorder. In the course of treatment Dr L became concerned that EK had developed eroticised transference issues and was applying pressure on him to commence a sexual relationship.
Dr L determined to cease treatment and referred EK to another practitioner. One year later, EK sought to recommence treatment with Dr L. Dr L agreed to recommence treatment. However, when EK again applied pressure for a personal relationship Dr L again ceased the treatment relationship. Five years after their last clinical contact, Dr L commenced a personal and sexual relationship with EK.
Dr L admitted that given the context of the treating history, this relationship was inappropriate even five years after all clinical contact had ceased.
Outcome
When the relationship came to light, the Medical Board took immediate action against Dr L. He ceased practice for over a year, before commencing a part-time private practice treating male patients only. He also commenced counselling.
The tribunal agreed that a 12-month suspension would ordinarily be appropriate. However, given Dr L had voluntarily removed himself from practice for 14 months previously, and clearly demonstrated insight, a further suspension was not warranted.
Dr L was reprimanded, counselling conditions were imposed and Dr L agreed to pay the Board’s costs.
Key lessons
The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists will not countenance a sexual relationship between a treating practitioner and a current or former patient under any circumstances.
- Give a firm and clear no, explaining it is unethical for you to enter a relationship with a patient. It is important not to be ambivalent or encouraging.
- Carefully document what has happened in the patient’s medical record (remembering that what you write may be read by the patient or others)
- Immediately inform a senior colleague, supervisor or practice manager and seek advice on whether you need to terminate the treating relationship.
References and further reading
Avant factsheet – Boundary issues
Medical Board of Australia Guidelines – Sexual boundaries in the doctor-patient relationship
Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists – Ethical Guideline 12: Zero tolerance policy on proven sexual boundary violations
More information
For medico-legal advice, please contact us here, or call 1800 128 268, 24/7 in emergencies.
Disclaimers
The case discussed in this publication is based on a real case. Certain information has been de-identified to preserve privacy and confidentiality. The information in this article does not constitute legal advice or other professional advice and should not be relied upon as such. It is intended only to provide a summary and general overview on matters of interest and it is not intended to be comprehensive. You should seek legal or other professional advice before acting or relying on any of its content.
Other resources
More ways we can help you
Our CPD courses for Avant members
Tick off some CPD hours and learn more with our in-depth eLearning courses, free for Avant members. Our courses include education activities, reviewing performance and measuring outcomes.