Compensation claims and complaints insights - general surgeons

Summary: Members asked us for more information about compensation claims and complaints to regulators. In response, the following is a retrospective review of routinely collected data.

Monday, 15 August 2022

Graph showing 6 bodies and 1 is highlighted.

Avant general surgeon members had a matter raised about the provision of their care.

Five year average FY2017-FY2021

Data source: matters indemnified FY2017-FY2021

The types of matters Avant assisted general surgeons with included:

Pie graph showing data for matters idemnified FY2017-FY2022. 45% regulatory complaints, 32% claims for compensation, 10% employment disputes, 8% coronial, 5% other (including Medicare)

Regulatory complaints and compensation claims against general surgeons related to:

68% procedural / surgical issues, 9% practitioner behaviour, 9% diagnosis, 7% consent, 8% other.

The nature of procedures commonly seen in procedural/ surgical matters

procedures on the digestive system (excluding bariatric surgery) (51%). Laparoscopic surgery (24%). Bariatric surgery (21%). Hernia procedures (19%).

(% out of total procedural/surgical matters shown)

The stage of care during which procedural/surgical issues occurred

19% pre-operative (e.g. improer selection of surgical procedure).60% Intra-operative (e.g. poor surgical performance).21% Post-operative (e.g. poor post-operative performance; delay/failure to diagnose complication).

Assessment of the care provided

General surgeons were assessed to meet the standard of care in procedural/surgical matters more than in other matters.

Procedural/surgical matters - 72% met the standard of care; 28% were below standard.Other matters - 57% met the standard of care; 43% were below standard.

Other matters

Allegations relating to practitioner behaviour included: failure to communicate results, inappropriate communication or disrespectful behaviour with a patient and boundary issues.

Allegations relating to diagnosis included: failure or delay in diagnosing a condition or a misdiagnosis.

Allegations relating to consent included: inadequate discussion about risks involved and not obtaining consent for specific treatments or procedures.

Key points

  • Procedural/surgical issues were the primary sources of complaints and claims for general surgeons. 
  • 51% of procedural/surgical allegations involved procedures on the digestive system (excluding bariatric surgery).
  • Other common procedural/surgical allegations arose with laparoscopic surgery and bariatric surgery. 
  • General surgeons were more likely to meet the standard of care expected in matters relating to procedural/surgical issues compared to other matters.

The above retrospective review is of routinely collected and coded data. Our review is based on 336 regulatory complaints and compensation claims involving Avant members who are general surgeons across Australia. All matters were closed over the five-year period from July 2016 to June 2021 (FY2017-FY2021).

Glossary

  • General surgeons are classified as those who hold FRACS or equivalent recognised qualification in general surgery.
  • Claims refers to claims for money, compensation and civil claims.
  • Complaints relates to formal complaints to regulators.
  • Matters include claims, complaints, coronial cases and other matters such as employment disputes and Medicare.
  • Employment disputes are matters where Avant defends members against complaints or supports members to resolve employment issues.
  • Medicare matters include Medicare investigations and audits.

Resources

If you receive a claim or complaint, contact us (avant.org.au/MLAS) on 1800 128 268 for expert medico-legal advice on how to respond – available 24/7 in emergencies.

For any queries on this analysis, please contact us at research@avant.org.au.

Disclaimers

IMPORTANT: Avant routinely codes information collected in the course of assisting member doctors in medico-legal matters into a standardised, deidentified dataset. This retrospective analysis was conducted using this dataset. The findings represent the experience of these doctors in the period of time specified, which may not reflect the experience of all doctors in Australia. This publication is not comprehensive and does not constitute legal or medical advice. You should seek legal or other professional advice before relying on any content, and practise proper clinical decision-making with regard to the individual circumstances. Persons implementing any recommendations contained in this publication must exercise their own independent skill or judgement or seek appropriate professional advice relevant to their own particular practice. Compliance with any recommendations will not in any way guarantee discharge of the duty of care owed to patients and others coming into contact with the health professional or practice. Avant is not responsible to you or anyone else for any loss suffered in connection with the use of this information. Information is only current at the date initially published.

Download this factsheet

Download PDF



Career stage
Topic

Other resources

  1. Education Plans - Avant

    Education Plans

  2. Real Time Prescription Monitoring Audit - Avant

    Real Time Prescription Monitoring - measuring outcomes audit

  3. Tribunal concludes sharing clinical images with friends was professional misconduct - Avant

    Tribunal concludes sharing clinical images with friends was professional misconduct

More ways we can help you

Indemnity insurance
Health insurance
Practice solutions
Finance
Legal services
Life & income protection
To Top

NSW State Office AddressLevel 6, Darling Park 3, 201 Sussex Street, Sydney NSW 2000
Telephone 02 9260 9000 | Facsimile 02 9261 2921

Mailing addressPO Box 746 Queen Victoria Building NSW 1230

Connect with Avant

facebookxlinkedininstagramyoutube

In the spirit of reconciliation, Avant acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of Country throughout Australia, and their connections to land, sea and community. As a national organisation, we pay our respects to Elders past and present, of the lands on which we gather and work, and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.

IMPORTANT: Professional indemnity insurance and the Practice Medical Indemnity Policy available from Avant Mutual Group Limited ABN 58 123 154 898 (Avant Mutual) are issued by Avant Insurance Limited, ABN 82 003 707 471, AFSL 238 765 (Avant). Avant Cyber Insurance cover is available to eligible Avant Practice Medical Indemnity Policy holders up to the cessation of their policy and is provided under a Group Policy between Liberty Mutual Insurance Company ABN 61 086 083 605 (Liberty) and Avant. Private health insurance products are issued by The Doctors’ Health Fund Pty Limited, ABN 68 001 417 527, a member of the Avant Mutual Group. Avant arranges Avant Business Insurance as agent of the insurer Allianz Australia Insurance Limited ABN 15 000 122 850, AFSL 234 708 (Allianz) and may receive a commission on each policy arranged. Avant Travel Cover is available under a Group Policy between QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, ABN 78 003 191 035, AFSL 239 545 (QBE) and Avant Mutual. Avant Travel Cover is underwritten by QBE and Avant may receive a benefit for arranging cover. Avant Finance is a registered business name of Avant Doctors’ Finance Pty Ltd (ACN 637 769 361) and licensed to Avant Doctors’ Finance Brokers Pty Ltd (ABN 75 640 406 784). Avant Doctors’ Finance Brokers Pty Ltd is a wholly owned subsidiary of Avant Doctors’ Finance Pty Ltd. Loan products may be provided by Avant Doctors’ Finance Pty Ltd or arranged by Avant Doctors’ Finance Brokers Pty Ltd. Credit services or assistance to which the National Credit Code applies are provided by Avant Doctors’ Finance Brokers Pty Ltd as authorised Credit Representative (Credit Representative Number 523242) for LMG Broker Services Pty Ltd ACN 632 405 504 Australian Credit Licence 517192. Legal services are provided by Avant Law Pty Ltd ABN 63 136 429 153 (Avant Law). Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. Legal practitioners employed by Avant Law are members of the scheme.


The information provided on this website is general advice only and has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation and needs. You should consider these, having regard to the appropriateness of the advice before deciding to purchase or continue to hold these products. For full details including the terms, conditions, and exclusions that apply, please read and consider the relevant Product Disclosure Statement or policy wording and Target Market Determination (TMD) which are available on this website or by contacting us on 1800 128 268. Information on this site does not constitute legal or professional advice, and is current as at the date of initial publication.